Royalty Audit Services
Data
Rate Utilization
(DRU) is a technique which RCO has perfected
over the past ten years. We
acquire the licensee output in digital (data) formats, Excel spreadsheets
or in hard copy formats then convert the data into a consistent,
understandable format. Our
team has extensive experience in converting files from paper and Excel
into refined, consistent data files.
DRU then allows us to perform a “completeness” test against the
actual results using the actual contract terms to produce an authentic,
objective analysis of royalty income. The end result from DRU confirms
higher audit claims since 100% of the reported data is analyzed.
These figures stand-up better during settlements and also help the
licensee identify weaknesses in their internal processes.
Royalty
Compliance Auditing in the License Industry
Royalty auditing in the licensing industry is designed to establish the
degree to which a user of protected creative property rights has
fulfilled the legal obligation to compensate the rights owner for such
use as was originally defined by contract. This is usually accomplished
through reviewing, investigating, and examining the books and records of
a license to determine if the reportings rendered by the license are in
compliance with the various provisions and requirements of the contract
between the two parties. The audit will include various procedures
reflecting the terms of the agreement, applied to the royalty accounting
records of the users. The results are then reported to the rights owner
for use in resolving any issues of non-compliance. The royalty audit
should provide solutions to royalty compliance and collection issues,
solve problems and clarify contractual issues, add to the bottom line
and provide valuable industry insight toward building stronger business
relationships between the parties.
The licensor may want procedures performed to provide comfort that their
copyrighted product is only being exploited under the terms, conditions
and methods as provided in the contract and as intended by the
licensor. Therefore, the scope of royalty auditing may be expanded to
include a study of the business practices of the licensee, verification
of quality control, and copyright protection.
Royalty audits may also be used to provide valuable insight into the
business practices of both parties. Quite often licenses are negotiated
and executed without either party having a full understanding of the
accounting requirements. In fact, many licensees are ill equipped to
fulfill the accounting and auditing provisions of the contract. Royalty
audits are often used for the purpose of educating both parties as to
their obligations in providing information to facilitate accurate and
complete accountings. If communication is the issue, the terms and
requirements may be clarified. If the problem lies within the
accounting system, recommendation may be made to obtain a royalty system
from a service provider or to obtain consulting services to build
internal capabilities. Finally, either party may use a royalty audit as
a source of data to prepare a valuation for mergers, or buy / sell
transactions.
In the licensing world, there has always been a tug of war as to who has
the power. Does the licensor need the licensee more to distribute their
product or does the licensee need the licensor to provide product for
distribution.
Usually, neither the licensor nor the licensee will want to offend the
other party. Although auditing is usually considered an adversarial
function. The company being audited may think of the audit as an
invasion of privacy and a disruption of their business. The company
requesting the audit may believe they have been cheated and
substantially underpaid. If the auditor is an adversary or if the sole
purpose of conducting an audit is to recover unpaid royalties then you
should consider changing auditors and reconsider the scope of the audit.
The very mention of the word audit gives rise to many questions:
1. What is an audit?
2. How will the audit affect the relationship between the licensor
and the licensee?
3. What are some of the other benefits of auditing?
4. What does an audit cost?
5. How is and audit conducted? / What procedures are involved?
6. What are some of the issues that may arise in an audit?
7. What authority provides audit rights?
8. What records should be made available? / What records should
not?
9. How is an auditor chosen?
10. How is it determined if an audit is warranted?
11. How are any issues discovered during the audit resolved?
These questions are answered in the following chapter pages ....
Click-
To continue reading the entire
paper by Wayne C. Coleman, CPA.
|